First published by: money.uk.msn
With £54 billion missing from council pension schemes, brace yourself for higher taxes.
Burgeoning pension fund deficits
could trigger a sharp hike in Council Tax
bills, a tax organisation has warned. Councils across the UK have a
combined pension deficit of more than £54 billion in 2010/11, according to new
research from The TaxPayers'
Alliance (TPA).
Put another way, the UK's 101
local authority pension funds have total liabilities calculated at £186.6
billion and total assets worth £132.4 billion. This difference represents a huge
'black hole' at the heart of the Local Government Pension Scheme (LGPS).
Your share could be £1,125
To put this £54 billion shortfall
into context, it averages out at £1,125 for each of the UK's 48 million adults.
Ultimately, taxpayers will be held liable for this deficit, so we could be
facing some steep increases in our Council
Tax bills, plus other local taxes such as parking charges and fines.
In previous research, TPA estimated that a fifth (20%) of
all Council Tax is spent on funding
employer contributions to the LGPS. In other words, if your Council Tax bill this year is £1,500,
then around £300 of this goes towards topping up your local council's sickly
pension scheme. As a result, TPA argues that the
LGPS is "much more generous than most private-sector pensions and is in
urgent need of reform."
The only good news is that this
huge deficit fell from £91 billion in 2009/10 to £54 billion in 2010/11,
largely thanks to a sharp recovery in share prices. Then again, this is still
£3 billion more than the £51 billion shortfall recorded in 2008/09, so things
have got worse instead of better since the recession.
20 councils with big 'black holes
According to TPA figures, these
10 councils had the largest pension deficits in 2010/11.
COUNCIL
|
DEFICIT (£M)
|
FUNDING LEVEL
|
DEFICIT PER PERSON
|
Birmingham
|
£1,340
|
67%
|
£1,292
|
Durham
|
£728
|
63%
|
£1,424
|
Hampshire
|
£718
|
64%
|
£554
|
Leeds
|
£650
|
75%
|
£814
|
Essex
|
£633
|
67%
|
£448
|
Lancashire
|
£629
|
73%
|
£538
|
Glasgow
|
£625
|
79%
|
£1,054
|
Brent
|
£582
|
42%
|
£2,267
|
Staffordshire
|
£568
|
66%
|
£684
|
Sheffield
|
£563
|
70%
|
£1,014
|
As you can see, Birmingham has
the biggest pension shortfall, weighing in at a hefty £1.34 billion, or £1,292
for each of its 1,037,000 citizens. Genteel Durham has the second-highest black
hole, at £728 million (£1,424 per head). In third place is Hampshire, with a
deficit of £718 million, which comes to £554 per head.
Another problem is that some
pension funds are much better funded than others. The average funding level for
all LGPS plans is 70% of their liabilities. However, of the top 20 councils,
three have assets worth less than three-fifths (60%) of their liabilities.
These are Brent (London), with a funding level of 42%, Rhondda, Cynon, Taff in
Wales at 53% and Welsh capital Cardiff, with a 58% funding level.
In total, TPA identified 26
councils with funding levels below this critical 60% level. Brent was the worst
by far, but other councils with pension-funding problems include Merthyr
Tydfil, South Wales (50%), Craven, North Yorkshire (52%), Worthing, West Sussex
(52%) and Havering, London (55%).
The biggest bills per head
TPA also identified those
councils with the highest pension shortfalls per head of population. These are
the 'top 10' in this category.
COUNCIL
|
DEFICIT (£M)
|
FUNDING LEVEL
|
DEFICIT PER PERSON
|
Merthyr Tydfil
|
£126
|
50%
|
£2,268
|
Brent
|
£582
|
42%
|
£2,267
|
Rhondda, Cynon, Taff
|
£483
|
53%
|
£2,063
|
Gateshead
|
£391
|
62%
|
£2,040
|
Neath, Port Talbot
|
£275
|
59%
|
£2,001
|
Hackney
|
£423
|
61%
|
£1,931
|
Hammersmith
and Fulham
|
£322
|
59%
|
£1,899
|
Newham
|
£413
|
61%
|
£1,718
|
Blaenau, Gwent
|
£117
|
65%
|
£1,708
|
Lambeth
|
£472
|
61%
|
£1,660
|
Merthyr Tydfil has a shocking
pension problem, with a deficit amounting to £2,268 per head, which is more
than double the £1,125 average I calculated above. Brent is just behind on
£2,267 per head and Rhondda, Cynon, Taff takes third place with a deficit per
person of £2,063.
While London and Wales dominate
the list above, the situation looks bleak across the country. This is a problem for every
household paying Council Tax
throughout the UK. Indeed, every one of the 434 councils in this survey - from
Aberdeen City to York - has a pension deficit, although it's a tiny £3 per head
at the Greater London Authority and in Chichester, West Sussex.
Pension promises we can't keep?
Frankly, I find this survey to be
deeply disturbing. Clearly, councils with huge pension black holes will have to
fill them somehow - and this burden will fall on ordinary taxpayers. However,
with Brits struggling to pay their own household bills and pension
contributions, it's a bit much to ask them to fork out an average £1,225 extra
per person towards sorting out council pensions, too. Hence, Matthew Sinclair, director
of the TaxPayers' Alliance, is calling on the government to urgently reform
pensions.
"The deficit in the Local
Government Pension Scheme remains a ticking time-bomb that's being left for
future generations of taxpayers to deal with," said Sinclair. "With
an ageing population and a crisis in the public finances, generous final-salary
schemes like the LGPS are inflexible and too expensive, and need urgent reform. "Councils should not take
false comfort in the improvement in the stock market. Their pension liabilities
continue to far outweigh their assets and the situation remains worse than two
years ago."
In summary, unless councils take
action to increase employee pension contributions, freeze current entitlements,
reduce future payouts and increase their retirement age to 65, then taxpayers
could be clobbered with yet more rounds of steep rises in Council Tax.
This will not be a welcome move,
especially as many councils have already ignored the call by Secretary of State
for Communities and Local Government Eric Pickles to
freeze Council Tax in 2012/13.
No comments:
Post a Comment
I support Council Tax Rebates in assisting home owners and tenants in getting a rebate on their over-paid Council Tax.